Andy Rubin to USA Today: Stop With the FUD

Andy RubinOk, so we’re pretty sure you all know about the recent Apple/Google Voice/AT&T story going on right now. The gist of it goes like this: Google Voice has been blocked from the App Store.  The FCC is looking into the matter to see who is behind it.  Apple using doublespeak, AT&T pointing fingers.  Google is going around them both by creating a web-based app with all the same functionality.

Everyone has picked up on this and is doing their part to report something on it.  USA Today ran an article yesterday implying that Google might be just as guilty of standing in the way of apps.  Unfortunately, the story is full of holes.  It’s so bad, that Andy Rubin took to the Google Public Policy Blog to address it.

Here are the facts, clear and simple: While the first generation of our Android software did not support full-featured VoIP applications due to technology limitations, we have worked through those limitations in subsequent versions of Android, and developers are now able to build and upload VoIP services.  – excerpt from Andy Rubin’s response

We feel somewhat obligated to add some more to the refutal.

Skype and Google Voice do not do the same thing. They might provide alternatives to traditional calling, but that’s about it.  Skype offers VOIP calling whereas Google Voice allows users to manage all their phones with a single phone number.

Android was not designed to handle VOIP when the Skype app was released.  After some updates to the SDK, developers now have the ability to create fully-featured VOIP apps using the new tools.  Neither Skype, nor anyone else, has offered up one yet.

Even if Google or a carrier decided to say ‘NO’ to allowing an app like Skype in the Android Market, the developer can still make it available.  Anyone can host an .APK file and allow users to download the app.  The Android Market is the biggest and best way to get apps, but it’s not the only.  Unless you have a jailbroken iPhone, there is only one way in.

One of the initial promises of Android was that once it’s out, there is essentially nothing that can be done to stand in anyone’s way.  If a company wants to make a phone with it, they can.  If someone wants to write an app for it, they can.  It doesn’t get much more simple than that.

About author

Scott Webster
Scott Webster 6579 posts

Scott has been running AndroidGuys since 2007 and loves nothing more than reading up on the latest smartphone rumors. His other mobile efforts can be found on Android Update (CNET) where he covers Google's mobile platform.

You might also like

News and Rumors

Starbucks to offer a wireless charging method that you likely won’t use

Wireless charging has always been extremely convenient way to get some extra juice, whether that be at home, at an airport, or in your car. But what about a coffee

News and Rumors

Skyfire 3.0 add the Facebook social layer to browsing.

Skyfire has been around for a little bit now. When I first used it, it felt like a second-rate browser. Skyfire emerged around the same time I was exploring Dolphin Browser HD and Opera Mini, and was really just noise. Noise that allowed me to watch Flash videos on certain sites, and that made it cool. Skyfire grew on Android until they were ready to blitz past the scathing, snide remarks of the iPhone fanboys at Engadget and Gizmodo to cause quite a sensation on two platforms. That’s a pretty serious achievement already, but it’s clear that the team at Skyfire doesn’t plan on slowing down with their 3.0 update!

News and Rumors

Dear Santa: Please Bring Me Widgets

The second part of the Android Developers Challenge should be getting off the ground before too long and I have a little Christmas wish to go with it.  Please release


  1. DarkFox
    August 22, 20:03 Reply

    "Neither Skype, nor anyone else, has offered up one yet."

    You are incorrect, is a very nice VoIP app for Android.

  2. Jonathan Lozinski
    August 24, 14:43 Reply

    sipdroid has offered up a voip client for SIP users. You do need to download the client from the website direct if you want voip over 3G but wifi works out of the box. It's a bit of a resource hog, but it works..

  3. James Bailey
    August 24, 20:03 Reply

    Where is this FUD coming from that says the iPhone doesn't allow VOIP? There are several SIP phone applications as well as several VOIP applications for the iPhone. The only thing you can't do is use AT&T's cellular service to make VOIP calls. Even if you could, you would be violating the terms of service you agreed to with AT&T. Using an Android phone wouldn't change that.

Leave a Reply