November 26, 2014

App Review: Photoshop.com for Mobile

pssplash Photoshop. For Android. Yes indeed, the premier image editing brand has launched a free app for Android, and without a doubt that is a feather in Android’s cap. But forgetting the big brand name for the moment, how does the app stack up on its own merits? It’s a solid app essential for users of Photoshop.com; not without faults, but a quick candidate for best free image gallery app.

Of course, you can’t install this app expecting all the features of CS4–or the props and word bubbles of PicSay. Photoshop.com Mobile has a fairly narrow focus: it’s a polished gallery replacement that syncs with online storage and has a few editing functions to touch up your photos.

Gallery Replacement
psgallery The stock Android photo gallery is pretty spartan, and Photoshop is a big improvement, allowing you to browse through pictures with intuitive swipes and select a batch of photos for a slideshow. The user experience is slick and professional but for one fly in the ointment: it’s difficult to find the photos you want to look at in the thumbnail view.

First, it displays ALL the images on your phone. So to find that picture of my dog I’m looking for, I have to scroll past pointers from My Maps Editor, avatars from twitter and facebook,  etc. They’re all lumped together with no options to sort or filter. Exacerbating that problem, the app reloads thumbnails each time you scroll past them–even if they just loaded a moment ago. You end up spending a lot of time looking at a black screen, waiting for thumbnails to load.

Other apps have better ways of handling this. Photo BURST, for example, first shows you all the folders on your sdcard that have images in them. You can then drill down to the images you want to look at. You can also address the issue by creating empty files named “.nomedia” and placing them in in directories that you don’t want gallery apps to index, but that’s not a solution the average user will avail himself of.

Photoshop.com
psupload2If you already have a Photoshop.com membership, this app will give you easy access to photos stored there. If you don’t, you’ll need to set up an account to use the app. A free account gets you 2Gb of cloud storage; paid accounts start at  $20/year for 20Gb. That’s not a great deal compared to what Google offers with Picasa ($5/year for 20Gb), but hey, free is free.

Syncing with Photoshop.com is where the app shines. As long as you have a data connection, you can browse through photos stored online just like you can with ones on your phone, effectively freeing up SD card space. It’s easy to batch upload photos to Photoshop.com, and an auto-upload option will automatically upload every photo you take.  Either way, uploads chug along in the background whether you’re still using the app or not.

Editing photos
psexpose Once I figured out that editing functions are not the main point of this app, I was no longer disappointed that there are only nine editing functions: crop, straighten, rotate, flip, exposure, saturation, tint, black&white, and soft focus. No laundry list of crazy filters, just a few tools to make photos look better.

I’d much rather have white balance than tint, but the functions you get are all really well done. Each is controlled with intuitive gestures and many have nice touches. For example, when you straighten a photo, the app also zooms a bit as you rotate, eliminating what otherwise would be empty spots in the corners. In addition, the app allows multiple levels of undo.

psstraighten

Rather than running through each function, I suggest you watch Adobe’s video tutorial. It does a great job of detailing every function of the app.

Other issues

  • When you set an image as wallpaper, it just decides for you how to crop it. Results are not always optimal:
pswallpaper1 pswallpaper2
  • It’s always running in the background, taking up 14K of memory. End it with a task killer, and it will come right back. This sort of thing bugs the heck out of me.

Reviewed Using: G1 running Cyanogen 4.2.3.1
Presentation: One of the most polished apps I’ve come across. It’s a joy to use.
Value: For free, you get a great photo gallery app and 2Gb of cloud storage. If you already use Photoshop.com, it’s a no-brainer.
Stability/Resources: While the app never lagged or crashed, it always runs in the background, coming back like a zombie no matter how often you kill it.
AG Says: While other apps best many of its features, Photoshop.com Mobile fills a niche. Photo BURST is a better gallery with better sharing options, but lacks editing functions; PicSay offers more powerful image editing but lacks the polish of Photoshop. And while full versions of both Photo BURST and PicSay are paid, Photoshop is free and comes with cloud storage features neither of the others offers.
Rating: **** 4 Stars



  • dadgineer

    Could not disagree with this review any more. Just because it is a polished app, it gets a good rating? I couldn't delete this app fast enough. I will take my non-polished, paid for, Picsay Pro any day over this app.

  • http://schwiz.net schwiz

    A gallery replacement with now share intent to upload to twitter, etc? Dealbreaker.

  • SiI

    Useless App…

    If you want photo editting, take a look at Foxy Editor – lite version does a lot of things or it's $3 for the full app.

  • http://twitter.com/brianjTwitt @brianjTwitt

    I thought the application was awesome, but I do not like that it is running as a service in the background. That's a dealbreaker and an uninstall for me!

    • http://www.androidtapp.com AndroidTapp.com

      For those concerned about the app constantly running in the background and worldwide availablitity, there's a fix/change coming soon. Brady Kroupa, Engineering Lead on Photoshop.com Mobile for Android, posted on my blog that this will be resolved soon: http://www.androidtapp.com/photoshop-com-mobile/c

  • Maff

    MASSIVE NEGATIVE POINT:
    they've only made it available to people in the US
    infuriates me!

  • Will

    Why are you running such an old version of cyanogenmod?

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/chuckfalzone Chuck Falzone

      Such an old version! It came out two weeks ago!

      I was using 4.2.3.1 for most of the time I was testing this app for the review. I'm currently running 4.2.5.

  • http://twitter.com/cym0n @cym0n

    I liked the app but after killing it over 10 times and watching it resurrect itself I uninstalled it. There is no reason a photo editing app should be running in the background always

  • Gary

    As a designer I live in photoshop on a daily basis and the Photoshop app completely sucks! If it could handle layers, it may have an edge up on the other billion (ok exaggerated) apps that can do the same thing if not more. I actually just downloaded an app on my iPhone that can handle psd files and layers within. So it can be done. Why Adobe chose to release a severely dumbed down app is beyond me but…I'm sure its just in hopes to get people using the online version of Photoshop – which any hard core designer knows is complete crap also.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/chuckfalzone Chuck Falzone

      I understand where you're coming from Gary, and for your purposes it does suck. But part of what I wanted to get across is that it's not aimed at hardcore designers. It's less like CS4 and more like Photoshop Album.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Davest010 Davest010

    It's so funny…another Android blog posted a negative review of this app, and there were dozens of comments criticizing the writer for being too negative. Here, a generally positive review is followed by comment after comment criticizing the reviewer for being too positive.

    Keep at it, Chuck. At least you're clearly using the apps you review, and your posts are well-written and thorough. I personally don't agree with your final rating, but you gave enough pros and cons to help us make up our minds for ourselves, which is really what these things are for anyway.

    Despite some of the other writers here (who shall remain nameless), your reviews will keep me coming back.

  • http://www.yarradigital.com Photo Retouching

    good enough to have a try, but just don't like it always running at background

  • http://nokiaphones.ws/ Administrator

    Does your comment pass the test? If you can answer positively to each of the above questions, chances are you have a good comment.

  • http://5530xpressmusic.com Ryan

    Its a nice cool application but i would have loved it even more with the option to reduce the image size/quality so that i can upload photos to my blog directly from my phone.I can put full images on my blog as it will consume lot of bandwidth.Is this app going to launch for Symbian touch phones?

  • http://www.sblgraphics.com image editing

    Cool application.
    Thanks.

  • http://www.jfhostreview.com choose best host

    I've always been waiting for a cool photoshop app for phones. awesome.

  • http://www.jfseostuido.com advanced seo

    i like the photoshop sync feature. Can do you have any more tutorials?

  • http://www.jfhostreview.com web host review

    looks like an awesome app.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/niniii0 niniii0

    I do not like that it is running as a service in the background. That's a dealbreaker and an uninstall for me!

  • https://muhammadf0628.student.ipb.ac.id cuppy

    great app.. i tried this is before..

  • http://www.logoonlinepros.com Business Logo design

    Very awesome article you have shared

    here. I have to confess your incredible

    effort. Thanks for sharing this captivating article
    stuff. Very informative and interesting points you mentioned. Great post!

    http://www.logoonlinepros.com

  • http://www.webdesignbizz.com/categories-real-estate-templates Real Estate Templates

    I thought the application was awesome, but I do not like that it is running as a service in the background.Thank you for sharing.

  • http://rareseeds.com/ Garden Seed

    Really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. I assure this would be beneficial for most of the people.

  • john peter

    I think you’ve made some truly interesting points.
    donate
    money

  • john peter

    complete link building Useful info. Hope to see more good posts in the future.