November 23, 2014

Call Delay Issue Plaguing Nexus One

Some Nexus One owners who rejoiced at getting Gingerbread in February have just weeks later begun griping about a bug in their phone’s version of Android 2.3.

Affected users report a 2-3 second delay after a phone call connects during which they can neither hear nor be heard by the person on the line. So far, over the course of  almost six weeks, more than fifty users have described the same issue on Google’s bug tracker for Android, and nearly 200 have starred the issue. Most are running stock Android 2.3.3, with a few running 2.3.3-based custom firmware.

With Gingerbread running on so few phones, it’s worth considering whether this is an issue with Gingerbread across the board or with the Nexus One’s specific build. No users in the bug tracker thread mention other models, but we did find references in various forums to the issue cropping up on the HTC Desire as well. We checked with a Nexus S owner as well as a Droid X owner who has flashed the recent Gingerbread build for that phone; neither had run into the issue.

So far, no Google employees have participated in the bug tracker thread. We reached out to Google for a comment, but have not heard back. With the Nexus One over a year old and no longer a flagship, it’s not clear how much attention the issue will receive.

In the mean time, those affected can try a third party app that claims to patch the problem. Unfortunately, Market reviews indicate the patch may not work consistently for everyone.

Nexus One and Desire owners, let us know in the comments if you’ve experienced this call delay issue and if so, how you are dealing with it.

  • http://profiles.google.com/daniel.friedmann Daniel Friedmann

    I have a rooted HTC Desire GSM with latest CM7. I just wait briefly before I start speaking. It’s annoying but I’ve become used to it meanwhile. Of course I hope that it’ll be fixed sooner than later.

  • hemlig

    The same issue has also been present in all (as far as I can tell) 2.3.3-based versions of the Oxygen 2.0.x (http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=971904, search the thread for the words “call delay”) mod for Desire GSM/Bravo.

    Sure it’s annoying some times, but something I can live with..

  • http://twitter.com/ju12zo Joey Izzo

    Damn, It that what that is? I just thought it was a problem with my bluetooth in my car. I feel like a schmuck saying hello 7 times before I get a hello back

  • Anonymous

    Both my wife and I are running CM7 on a Desire GSM and a Milestone, respectively, and neither one of us have experienced this issue.

  • Anonymous

    Both my wife and I are running CM7 on a Desire GSM and a Milestone, respectively, and neither one of us have experienced this issue.

  • Asd

    Desire GSM with C7 has this issue too.

  • Michael

    I’ve had the problem…just have to wait, sometimes I say hello twice

  • JR

    I have this problem too… I would say more like 1-2 seconds..and like Michael said..you find yourself saying hello twice. I am learning to wait because you can almost hear the connection kick in…

  • Rootko

    I have it too. Running RC3 of CM7, I was kinda hoping, this will go away with final release. I guess I’ll have to get used to this :(

  • http://twitter.com/Geathan Geathan A.

    The best workaround for now is an app from a dev over at XDA called Dewonkificator. You can get it here http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=935250

  • http://www.facebook.com/victorstuber Victor Stuber

    I have this issue and it sucks because I start getting aggravated before the person even hears me.
    I’ve just learned to wait 3 seconds before speaking

  • Mikey

    I get it too. I feel somewhat better knowing it’s a widespread issue for us Nexus One owners. Not a big deal though, By the time I “answer” the phone and actually say “Hi” it’s over the 1-2 second period anyway. Still, it would be nice to have a fix.

  • JJVK

    I have a Nexus One running gingerbread and a Droid incredible one phone for work and one for personal they both have the delay issue. I think it is an Android problem.

  • John

    I get that too, and i thought it was the carrier. Nexus One 2.3.3. stock

  • Capndan

    Until I read this I didn’t realize it was happening to me, but it explains a lot why I have to say hello about 3 times before anyone will talk to me lately.

  • M4006

    me too

  • Planetmike

    My native N1 (not rooted) is running fine on 2.3.3 under T-Mobile in the States.

  • xanfan

    Like Capndan, I didn’t realize it was happening to me until I read this but I do have to wait a couple of second before I say hello.

  • UbuntuMan

    With stock Gingerbread 2.3.3, never had the issue. However this issue appeared when I installed CM7.

  • Nexus7

    Have noticed it since the update, that and I had some keyboard issues and the screen going blank before and after calls, having to press power and sometimes even reboot. Nexus One owner running stock Android 2.3.3. Looks nice , but by far the flakiest version of android. 2.2.2 was rock solid.

  • Lloyd

    yes I have a number of times, I thought it was the phone on the other end. Thx

  • Lloyd

    yes I have a number of times, I thought it was the phone on the other end. Thx

  • Mister Heartbreak

    No problems with my unrooted N1.

  • http://twitter.com/tadejkolino Tadej Rudec

    It’s the mic’s issue, probably lib’s from official HTC Gingerbread ROM will solve it.

  • Melonmotion

    Had Gingerbread 2.3.3 on my Nexus one since February with no problems! My wife is running a nexus s with no problems…

  • Anonymous

    Droid X here, running rooted leaked GB. No problems for me.

  • Techniciancraig

    n1 cm7 …… i have that bug, thought it was just me lol

  • Jimmy P

    Been a problem on CM builds for some people, Dewonkificator works for me on CM7.
    Link posted further down the page by Geathan A.

  • Dave

    N1 CM7 … I have it too. Though I have also experienced my whole phone gettimg severely unresponsive since upgrading, so perhaps I have a different problem going on.

  • clemont

    i have the same problem… running htc desire with cm7…

  • Ravi

    Nexus one with stock 2.3.3. I did notice after the upgrade, I had to say hello 2 or 3 times before I get a response. Now I just wait 2 seconds before saying hello! This article confirmed my suspicion that gingerbread is responsible.

    Also random screen blanking issues after call or after tapping on a contact.

    Mis-recognition of touches sometimes, needing reboot.

    Touching the green call icon next to a contact name often results in a black screen.

    Many many flaky issues with gingerbread. Froyo was delightfully robust and a much more pleasing, detailed skin too compared to the black mess of gingerbread.

    • robbid

      Also having the weird touch issue where it’s like the recognition is off.

    • robbid

      Also having the weird touch issue where it’s like the recognition is off.

    • A S

      N1 here with stock Gingerbread as well. I have experienced the call delay also. But the most frustrating problem for me is the random screen blanking. The screen shows the wall paper with no other icons, widgets, etc. The phone basically becomes a brick with a nice wall paper. It is extremely frustrating when this happens, especially when you want to make a call or access some information in an hurry.

  • TeeDubb

    Nexus One with CM7 RC4. I’ve been experiencing it in all the CM7 release candidates. Dewonkificator fixes the issue.

    Planning to do a full wipe and CM7 final install tonight. Hopefully, that will do the trick. If not, I’ll reinstall the utility. It’s a small price to pay for the most hackable and tweakable phone out there. :)

  • Casper Bang

    Yup, got the issue too. CM7.

  • Casper Bang

    Yup, got the issue too. CM7.

  • guest

    I’m having this same issue on my HTC desire. Running the latest nightlies from CyanogenMod7. The same issue is there on my other phone which is a Nexus One(stock gingerbread).

  • AJ

    I’m just glad I’m not alone. I have been wondering what was up. Google, if you are reading this, please fix it.

  • Ggliwanag

    Dewonkificator ftw!

  • Michaelrice15

    Had this issue for awhile now. Ever since the first cm7 build came out. I also thought it was just me.

  • robbid

    My partner and I have the Nexus One with Gingerbread and we are both experiencing this problem.

  • Aja

    I too have a stock Nexus one and since updating to 2.3.3 I have to wait a few seconds to before anyone can hear me. It’s rather annoying.

  • UbuntuMan

    End up switching back to stock Gingerbread. Now no more delay.

    So the question is, is it CM7 or in general Gingerbread?

  • Cb474

    If you’re having the call delay problem, especially on a device that is not the Nexus One, please star the issue here:

    http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=16230

    This is a known bug with Gingerbread, that Google recently declined, saying it was “device specific” (to the Nexus One).

    However this problem is also being reportedly widely on the HTC Desire, as well as Samsung Galaxy devices. I have posted a new issue above and not attributed it to a specific device.

    Please comment and star this issue. And please specificy especially if your device is not the Nexus One, so that Google gets this message that this is a widespread Gingerbread bug, which has nothing to do with the device.

    Thanks.

    • cb474

      The Google employee following up on the call delay issue, in the Google support forums, is asking people to fill out the following form, to gather information about how people are affected and on what devices.

      http://goo.gl/10HJ1

  • Nousheeralam

    i have the same issue with my nexus one