Platform Wars: A Meditation on the Amazon Kindle Fire and the B&N NOOK Tablet

Platform Wars: A Meditation on the Amazon Kindle Fire and the B&N NOOK Tablet


Last night on the weekly podcast, we discussed the Amazon Kindle Fire and the new Barnes & Noble NOOK Tablet, or,  the artist formerly known as the NOOK Color.  Are these actual e-Readers evolving into real tablets or are we witnessing the convergence of gadgets to come?

The e-Reader market has essentially splintered into two definitive platforms: Amazon and B&N.  While Apple and Google both deliver books to their respective devices, the iPad and everything else, they have not caught on with consumers like the greyscale, often 7-inch, e-Readers.  It seems that anything larger than seven inches is not considered as portable and easy to use possibly because of its weight.  But even with those differences, here is why I believe that the new Kindle Fire and NOOK Tablet will grow and continue to dominate their market niche: The Platform.

Amazon is marketing its own Whispersync technology (The Continuous Client), the Silk browser (cached content that is powered by AWS), and of course the e-Books.  While B&N is more traditional in its approach with e-Books and they have a tried and true ‘click and mortar’ strategy with their network of retail stores and kiosks across North America.  Now you may say, ah but the Kindle Fire is sold in Best Buy, etc.  But that’s just a stand-alone device with a small marketing booth whereas the NOOK Tablet is plastered wall-to-wall in many of its stores and a simple question to anyone working in the store will certainly elicit a response, “Have you thought about our NOOK Tablet?”.  Sold.

So how did this turn into a Platform War?  Easy.  If you are reading this, it is safe for me to assume that you have probably have cable/satellite service, an almost 99% possibility that you either have an Android based phone (and/or an iPhone), and maybe even an e-Reader/tablet.  Other than the look and the feel of the product we tend to buy for the service quality and content on the before mentioned devices.  For iOS it may be for apps, for Android it could be because it’s the anti-iOS, etc, etc.  But for services like satellite television services it’s largely a services play.  Not too often do you hear people talke about their set-top boxes and compare specs and UI, not even us geeks.  Nope, what we care about are the service plans, channel and content delivery, and price.  Possibly in a different order, but that’s usually how it goes.  While some services may be region plays, that’s not so with WiFi based devices so there isn’t a Verizon vs. AT&T quality of service issue(s) based on location.

What Amazon is selling is a content delivery device based on services.  The Kindle and NOOK families are essentially set-top boxes for content with built in screens.  Yeah, so apps could be considered the same thing but apps can rise above a platform and be written for multiple OS’es, and be everywhere thus minimizing the specialness of the platform.  Just like the same television channels can be viewed on different service platforms.

 Amazon delivers:

  • Whispersync
  • Silk Browser
  • Enormous e-Book library
  • Amazon Prime
  • Movies and Music
  • Android Apps
  • Retail ubiquity

B&N brings to the Party:

  • Physical retail locations for “try before you buy” experiences in a fully B&N controlled environment
  • Building on top of the NOOK Color legacy as one of the most hacked Android devices ever
  • Enormous e-Book library
  • Same basic form factor as the NOOK Color but a little thinner and lighter so no need to buy new cases

So essentially there is a new paradigm of devices that depend largely on cloud connectivity for streaming and content.  The Cloud will keep content sync’d across multiple platforms like the Kindle e-Books that will bookmark the last page on one device and enable reading forward on another one.  B&N can do the same with its app as well.  So in closing, these new e-Readers AKA tablets should be approached and decided upon for their ecosystems, content library, and price.  But for my money, I’d love a new Kindle Fire in my Christmas stocking.

Order a Kindle Fire from






About author

You might also like

News and Rumors

“End of October and Onwards” Sony Ericsson Delays 2.1 Update for Xperia Line

Sony Ericsson has officially pushed back the much-anticipated Android 2.1 update for their Xperia line of phones. Originally slated for Q3, the company now says the “revised plan is to start the roll-out from end of October and onwards”. Citing a need to ensure the right quality and user experience, SE’s announcement is likely going to ruffle a few feathers.

News and Rumors

ReVault: World’s first wearable private cloud

It is often said that more memory space on a phone is unnecessary with the advancements in cloud storage. People have gone as far as saying that on-board memory and

News and Rumors

ZTE to make Boost Mobile debut with the ZTE Warp

ZTE, a company that we primarily see across the lake in places like Korea, has decided to give the U.S. some love with their newly announced “ZTE Warp.” The company


  1. Vincent Femia
    November 17, 11:53 Reply

    Can’t the nook also load the Kindle reading app?  More storage as well.  So netflix + kindle + B&N bookstore= better than the Fire?  I’m actually torn between which device to grab.  I haven’t seen a  full review on the Nook Tablet yet, but that will definitely help my decision.

    • Anonymous
      November 17, 12:04 Reply

      Actually, I would choose the Fire b/c I already have more than a few Kindle e-Books but yes, pound for pound the NOOK has better specs but I prefer the Kindle form factor.

      • Vincent Femia
        November 17, 12:17 Reply

        This is going to be my first e-book reader so I don’t have books from either store.  I do have Amazon Prime though, which was a huge selling point for the Fire, but since the Nook has Netflix and the ability to sideload the Kindle app ( can’t we have the best of both worlds with the Nook?  I’m not partial to either, but I’m trying to see the benefit of the Fire over the Nook.  The reviews I read for the Fire weren’t great either (Engadget and BGR).  

        • Anonymous
          November 17, 12:22 Reply

          I already have Netflix on my Moto XOOM so that’s not an issue for me but I am anxious to see both in person very soon. 

          • Vincent Femia
            November 17, 12:29

            Awesome, just hoping to see a few reviews of the Nook before I buy either one next week!  I was so dead set on a Fire, but the reviews really stole the wind from my sails on that.

  2. David Berkowitz
    November 18, 17:34 Reply

    Personally I prefer the Color Nook Tablet.I like it a bit better. If we can get sent one of each we could evaluate them. We could then donate them to help autistic kids education. An aspie run, android luvin’ autism nonprofit.

Leave a Reply