December 21, 2014

Please stop freaking out about Facebook Messenger, it's nothing new

Screen Shot 2014-08-12 at 3.45.57 PM

Over the past few days my Facebook News Feed has been blowing up with people saying that the Facebook Messenger app is an over invasion of privacy, “do not download it,” or that it’s ridiculous to have to download another app. Most of this is all because people are finally looking at permissions that they had granted Facebook all along, even on the main Facebook app.

What started in April with Facebook beginning to require its European users to download and install the app if they wanted to send messages to other Facebook users is now expanding to other regions around the world. Facebook says that it’s forcing its user to make the switch because having a standalone app makes more sense and allows them to offer more features.

Some of the features in addition to the standard text chatting, is the ability to take an instant photo so you can take a “selfie” or even one with the rear camera without having to open up the camera app, send voice messages, send videos and stickers and make calls.

Having used the Facebook Messenger app since it launched in 2011, it’s one of my favorite apps and allows me to chat with my friends much easier than having to navigate through the main Facebook app. It has also greatly improved over the years as well. One thing that I’m not sure if it was offered in the main app with messaging but you get in Facebook Messenger are Chat Heads, one of the best features, in my opinion, that Facebook has ever come up with and greatly improves the messaging experience, especially on Android since they pop up on the homescreen too and you can access chats without having to go into the app.

As I said above, I think most people are hesitant to download it and looking for ways around it because they are reading the permissions for the first time, even though they’ve always granted these permissions to the Facebook app. An old Huffington Post story is also leading people to believe that with this app, Facebook is spying on them.

To set the record straight, all you’re really allowing the app to do is

  • have access to your Facebook account, so it can identify the Facebook user (you), you can then sign into the app easily if you’re already signed into the main app
  • read your contacts so you can send messages or call your friends
  • access your location so it can geotag photos or tell your friends your location, which can also be turned on or off, even in specific chats
  • access your SMS, so you can send and receive text messages, you can even use this as your default text messaging app
  • access your phone so that you can use the app to make calls if you chose to, plus you will know who is calling you if they’re in your contacts
  • access to Photos/Media/Files, so you can access photos and videos on your device to share with friends, save files from friends, and even so you can save photos that you take with the Messenger app
  • access to camera and microphone so you can take photos and videos and even call friends, otherwise these features won’t work
  • access Wi-Fi connection information so you can connect to a wireless network to be able to send messages and make calls to friends, basically use the app’s features
  • access Device ID and call information to make outgoing calls

That’s pretty much it. All you’re doing is giving the app permission to work. Facebook’s terms are the same on all of its mobile apps and if you’re using any of the other ones or even the desktop interface, you probably already approved all this before. Just about all of these features have also been available in the main app.

These are also no different than nearly any other messenger app, whether you’re using WhatsApp, SnapChat, Line, Skype or Hangouts.

Screen Shot 2014-08-12 at 6.15.49 PM

Now besides these overhyped privacy issues, some may say that they just don’t want to download another app. That may be an inconvenience to have another app on your smartphone or tablet, but it is only about 38 MB so it’s not going to use up a ton of your storage. Facebook will probably be cutting messaging from the main app soon too, so that means that the main app will most likely get smaller.

In the end, all I have to say is that Facebook Messenger isn’t scary and nothing new is being introduced. Facebook may be implementing these changes, but just as with all changes to Facebook, you can’t stop them. It’s a free app and you can chose whether you want to use it or not. No one is forcing you. It is still one of the easiest and best ways to keep up to date with news and to keep in contact with all your friends and family.

Perhaps Facebook has gone a bit far in the past few years and our trust with them has dwindled a bit, but it seems there really is nothing to worry about with the app. Hopefully they will release some sort of official statement in the coming days and weeks. If you’re truly concerned, you could try to contact Facebook.

Facebook Messenger just makes the instant messaging part a little bit easier on mobile by separating it out.



  • Pingback: Please stop freaking out about Facebook Messenger, it’s nothing new - DigiWatching - DigiWatching

  • Chad McVeigh

    Thanks for this post! I knew the freak out about this was much ado about nothing! Nothing was changing in regards to permissions. These permissions, like you said, just allow the app to function. A local channel here in Portland had this as a news story. I felt they were promoting the freak out of the app permissions being an invasion of privacy. I will be sharing this post.

  • Pingback: Please stop freaking out about Facebook Messenger, it’s nothing new | otroandroidblog

  • Jake

    Sorry, but I wouldn’t trust Facebook with any of those permissions, new or not. They’re likely storing your contacts on their servers so they can match your friends with their phone numbers, even if you don’t want them to.

  • IHateLies

    Its not that I care about the app. I run Android and have root access. I run App Ops and disable all permissions to apps that don’t need access to functionality I don’t want them to have. I like to compartmentalize things.

    Messenger may not be any more intrusive than other messaging apps and platforms.

    The problem is Facebook is monetizing everything it can, as well as manipulating the content of its medium, without giving people any mechanism to control the opt in.

    So while it can become the default messaging app, the company will eventually harvest the content to determine what ads to send to you. Even if you don’t make it the default app, what are the security mechanisms that are available to the non-techies?

    And even then, how much can the technically savvy people be that even the settings we find ways to enable won’t have FB working hard to get around.

    But hey, its all “free”.

  • Taradino C.

    Facebook says that it’s forcing its user to make the switch because having a standalone app makes more sense and allows them to offer more features.

    That may be what they’re saying, but it’s not true. A standalone app doesn’t allow them to offer any more features than a combined app, especially if they aren’t requesting any new permissions.

    Facebook Messenger just makes the instant messaging part a little bit easier on mobile by separating it out.

    That’s not true either. Having to install and update a separate app makes messaging more complicated, not easier. Easy is sending messages with the app that’s already installed.

  • Pingback: Please stop freaking out about Facebook Messenger, it’s nothing new | The Today Online

  • Pingback: Please stop freaking out about Facebook Messenger, it’s nothing new - AIVAnet

  • D-Vasive

    Get D-Vasive and stop other apps from spying on you! Our app will alert you when another app tries to access your Camera, Mic, Bluetooth and WiFi. It also lets you lock down your Camera, Mic, Bluetooth and WiFi so no other apps can possibly access them!

    Try it for FREE today!

    Google: dvasive